Capstone: Evaluation Rubrics

 Problem Solving Rubric - A1c Planning an Event or Activity

Category

Below Standard

Meets Standard

Exceeds Standard

Purpose of

the Project

· Lacks sufficient evidence of use of content standards as a rationale for planning the event or activity

 

· Utilizes content standards as a basis for the rationale for planning, and as an integrated component of the event or activity

· Presents evidence that references the problem or the need for the event or activity

· Utilizes content standards from a variety of disciplines as a rationale for planning and as integral components of the event or activity

 

 

Plan

· Shows insufficient research of relevant precedents and regulations

· Fails to include important details or to reflect the goals of the event or activity in the planning schedule

· Demonstrates that proper research into relevant precedents and regulations has been completed

· Writes a logical and achievable planning schedule that efficiently uses the resources available and reflects the goals of the event or activity

· Demonstrates in-depth research into a broad range of precedents and regulations

· Develops a very detailed planning schedule that facilitates implementation and takes into account the goals of the event or activity

 

Implementation

· Omits details in schedule or fails to make key steps clear or fails to demonstrate completion of the event or activity

· Fails to adjust the schedule to compensate for unforeseen circumstances

· Uses time, money, people, resources or facilities inefficiently

· Writes a schedule that is clear and easily understood by the intended audience and clearly describes the steps necessary to put the plan into action

· Adjusts the schedule in ways that reflect the established criteria and responds to unforeseen circumstances

· Makes efficient use of time, money, people, resources and facilities

· Writes a schedule that is clear, easily understood by peers, and includes annotations of documentation or background necessary for the various steps of the schedule

· Adjusts the schedule in a manner that reflects reaction as well as anticipation to established priorities and unforeseen circumstances

· Makes excellent use of time, money, people, resources and facilities within the schedule

Results

· Fails to communicate the results of the project, and the criteria used to judge the quality of the design

· Communicates the results of the project and the criteria used to judge the quality of the design

· Communicates the results of the project in a variety of forms and provides a detailed explanation of the criteria used to judge the quality of the design

Evaluation

· Uses inappropriate or insufficient quantitative and/or qualitative methods to evaluate the completion of the event or activity

· Does not include or shows insufficient reflection on recommendations for future events or activities

· Evaluates the completed event using appropriate qualitative and/or quantitative methods in terms of the established criteria

· Makes recommendations for others planning a similar event or activity in the future

 

· Evaluates the completion of the event or activity using a variety of quantitative and/or qualitative methods

· Makes well-constructed and thoughtful recommendations for planning and organizing subsequent similar events or activities