Category

Below Standard

Meets Standard

Exceeds Standard

Design Ideas

· Demonstrates limited ideas for the design, which may not reflect awareness of similar work done by others and relevant design standards and regulation

· Demonstrates clear ideas for the design, which reflects awareness of similar work done by others and relevant design standards and regulations

· Demonstrates sophisticated ideas for the design of the service or system, which reflects awareness of similar work done by others and relevant design standards and regulations

Choices

· Lacks justification of choices made in finalizing the design

· Justifies choices made in finalizing the design in terms of functional, aesthetic, social, economic, and environmental considerations

· Provides detailed justification of choices made in finalizing the design in terms of functional, aesthetic, social, economic, and environmental considerations

Establishing Criteria

· Lacks criteria for evaluation of the product, service or system

· Lacks appropriate conventions to represent the product, service or system

· Demonstrates thought in establishing criteria for evaluating the product, service or system

· Uses appropriate conventions to represent the design

· Demonstrates considerable thought in establishing criteria for evaluating the product, service, or system

· Uses sophisticated conventions to represent the design

Implementation

· Does not provide description of the steps needed to plan and implement the product, service or system.

· Lacks evidence of adjustments made to conform with specified standards or regulations regarding quality or safety

· Provides evidence of good planning and implementing of steps needed to create the product, service, or system

· Identifies adjustments made to conform with specified standards or regulations regarding quality or safety

· Provides a detailed outline of the planning and implementation steps necessary to create the product, service or system

· Describes creative adjustments made to conform with specified standards or regulations regarding quality or safety

Product Evaluation

· Exhibits limited evaluation of the product, service or system in terms of the criteria established in the design proposal and with reference to information gathered

· Does not provide sufficient comparisons with similar work done by others

· Provides thoughtful evaluation of the product, service, or system in terms of criteria established in the design proposal and with reference to information gathered

· Demonstrates relevant comparisons with similar work done by others

· Provides sophisticated evaluation of the product, service or system in terms of the criteria established in the design proposal and with reference to information gathered

· Provides accurate and in-depth comparisons with similar work done by others