|
Category
|
Below Standard
|
Meets Standard
|
Exceeds Standard
|
|
Design Ideas
|
· Develops a paper that is not analytical and fails
to demonstrate how the ideas for the paper were formulated
|
· Develops an analytical, critical paper that
demonstrates how the ideas for the paper were formulated
|
· Develops an analytical, critical paper that
provides a detailed description of how the ideas for the paper were
formulated
|
|
Research
|
· Lacks awareness of similar work done by others in
an unacceptable literary form
|
· Reflects awareness of similar work done by others
and presents it in an acceptable literary format
|
· Reflects thorough understanding of similar work
done by others and presents it in a acceptable literary format
|
|
Choices
|
· Lacks justification of choices with little or no
references to functional, aesthetic, social, economic, or environmental
considerations
|
· Justifies choices made with reference to
functional, aesthetic, social, economic, or environmental considerations
|
· Demonstrates sophisticated justification of
choices with reference to functional, aesthetic, social, economic, or
environmental consideration
|
|
Establishing Criteria
|
· Lacks establishment of criteria for analysis,
developmental and critiquing of the topic
|
· Establishes criteria for analysis, developmental
and critiquing of the topic
|
· Establishes detailed criteria for analysis,
developmental and critiquing of the topic
|
|
Implementation
|
· Does not establish criteria for analysis,
developmental and critiquing of the topic
|
· Demonstrates evidence of planning and implementing
of development of the topic
|
· Demonstrates sophisticated evidence of planning
and implementing of development of the topic
|
|
Grammar
|
· Demonstrates poor use of conventions to establish
the topic
|
· Uses appropriate conventions to establish the
topic
|
· Demonstrates sophisticated use of appropriate
conventions to establish the topic
|
|
Product Analysis / Evaluation
|
· Provides insufficient evidence of analytical,
critical, and developmental thinking of the topic in terms of research and
comparison of similar work done by others
|
· Demonstrates thoughtful evaluation of analytical,
critical, and developmental thinking of the topic in terms of research and
comparison of similar work done by others
|
· Demonstrates sophisticated evaluation of
analytical, critical, and developmental thinking of the topic in terms of
research and comparison of similar work done by others
|